As with other construction materials,
quality levels can vary widely in architectural cast stone.
The lowest quality level is made from
a soupy garden-variety concrete that is poured into molds. Elements cast
from soupy concrete have lower strength than dry-tamped material, are
prone to "bug holes" from trapped air, and are more properly termed
"precast concrete."
DRY-CAST FORMULATIONS
True cast stone is a portland-cement-based concrete product made using
high-quality coarse and fine aggregates, such as limestone, marble,
granite, or quartz. Other ingredients such as
pigments, pozzolans, and chemical admixtures may also be added. Admixtures
can include plasticizers, air-entraining agents, water-reducers, etc.
Using a high ratio of fine aggregate creates a smooth, dense,
consistent surface for cast building elements, with a very low level of
water absorption -- which makes them very durable even when exposed
to frequent freeze-thaw cycles.
High-quality cast stone is usually produced with a low water-to-cement
ratio. This "dry" mix is packed into molds using vibration
under pressure, or air-driven
tampers. Elements produced in this way are often called VDT
(vibrant-dry-tamped) cast stone.
WET-CAST FORMULATIONS
Cast-stone products made by the wet-casting method are required to meet
the same specifications as VDT-cast products. Air-entraining agents, for
example, can increase the durability of wet-cast concrete: having around
5% entrained air substantially increases the ability of wet-cast concrete
to resist freeze-thaw cycles and meet ASTM standards.
Other types of admixtures, such as
water-reducers, super plasticizers, and self-compacting additives can
also increase the strength and durability of wet-cast concrete
so that it approaches the performance level of VDT-cast elements.
CONTROLLING CAST-STONE QUALITY
Both careful specifications and care in production are essential to creating
strong, durable, good-looking cast-stone elements. Cast stone manufactured
to high standards will have such characteristics as: (a) Hard, razor-sharp
edges; (b) A fine-grained surface like natural stone; (c) No visible air
holes. A cast-stone producer should conduct regular quality-control
tests on the consistency of the raw materials (e.g. the aggregates), the
manufacturing process, and the final product.
The prudent client will take steps to make sure that the manufacturer
performs adequate quality control testing and that the product meets ASTM
standards. Alternately, or in addition, the client might also conduct
its own random on-site testing and inspection at the plant to ensure that all
specifications and quality standards are being met.
THERE'S MORE . . .
The accompanying list of cast-stone suppliers
has been culled from recent issues of Traditional Building magazine.
Each issue of TRADITIONAL BUILDING magazine
contains 16 or more
such reports covering products and services used in restoration,
renovation, and historically inspired new construction. If you would
like to subscribe, please visit our
subscription
page.
Click here for Suppliers of CAST STONE
Click here for Previous Product Reports