Small Mast

The Traditional Metal Roof

There's been a surge of interest in metal roofing. Here's a survey of the most common types and what specifiers need to know about finding the right metal roof for your project.

by Tom Black, Executive Director, Metal Roofing Alliance

 The Washington Monument. Thomas Jefferson's Monticello. Metal roofs have been around for centuries, and in some cases, original metal roofs have been a distinctive characteristic on famous old buildings. By the late 1700s, zinc, copper, and lead were the most popular materials used for roofing and could be found in well-established cities. These metals, however, were very expensive because of the cost of hand-worked materials.

After 1850, mass production, railroads, and more-lightweight materials all helped to reduce the cost of installing a metal roof. More homeowners, from a wide range of socioeconomic classes, were able to afford metal roofs. Corrugated iron, the popular material at this time, was found most often on farm structures, public buildings, and simple homes.

 By the mid-20th century, new styles and varieties of metal-roofing systems emerged. Sheets of metal were being shaped to resemble wood shakes, slate, or terra cotta. Roll forming contributed to the variety of metal-roofing materials. Metal could now be cut into longer panels and could be manufactured to improve shaping flexibility -- creating the appearance of individual pieces within panels.

TYPES OF METAL ROOFS
 
ATAS International's standing seam roofing was used on this traditional covered bridge.

 
Standing Seam
Standing-seam metal roofs have been popular for centuries. The term standing seam is used to describe any type of joinery that uses an upturned portion of the metal to connect adjacent metal sections. The joinery raises the seam above the drainage plane of the panel, creating its distinctive vertical lines.

In the past, the original standing-seam roof involved only the 90-deg. adjacent metal upstands that could be single or double folded at the top. Today standing-seam joints are held together with a concealed clip, or cleat, at the seam. The clip involves a male and a female upstand that joins with or without seaming. Other versions of standing seam incorporate a nailing flange to the roof, which is then covered up by the next panel as it is snapped into place.

 Standing-seam metal roofs are used with many types of high-pitched expanses of roof that can be enhanced with strong definition of the architectural lines. Standing-seam roofs are also very prevalent in mountainous regions where the need to shed snow is important. In addition, standing-seam installation is sometimes easier than other roofing styles.

Standing-seam metal sheets go through a roll-forming process to create the panels. The roll-formed panels are custom cut to the specific lengths of the roofs. Because they are custom cut, the product is usually special-ordered for each job.


 
Shingles and Tiles
Metal roofs can also be made to resemble wood shakes, clay tiles, shingles, and Victorian metal tiles. To create the desired look, aluminum or coated steel can be pressed or formed into individual realistic shapes. Individual shingles or tiles work best when roofing a home that has curving roof planes or intricate roofs.

Conversely, sheets of aluminum or pre-coated steel, approximately 4 feet in length, are pressed into modular panels through a stamping process creating the look of individual shingles, shakes, slates, or tiles. The benefit of this type of roofing is that it is designed for quick installation; installers only have to work with one larger piece as opposed to numerous smaller pieces. Available through regular distribution channels, modular panels are readily obtainable.

In addition, metal sheets can also go through both processes -- roll forming and stamping. These panels receive roll-form elements, but also are stamped into consistent patterns on one large sheet.

METAL TYPES

Galvanized or Galvalume Steel

 
This traditional Victorian uses Conklin Metal Industries' metal shingle roofing.

 Galvanized steel is the most common metal choice for a metal roof. The material is affordable and offers excellent structural capabilities. Plain steel is coated with a layer of hot-dipped commercially pure zinc to provide corrosion protection. Zinc is considered a sacrificial element and works well as a metallic coating. When the metal is cut or damaged, the zinc coating will protect that area from corrosion. Galvanized steel is warranted against corrosion for up to 20 years and offers excellent barrier protection. Galvanized metallic coatings are designated G-30, G-60, and G-90. This means that the weight of zinc on the steel is 30.-, 60.-, or 90-oz. per square foot, counting both the top and the bottom side of the sheet. The Metal Roofing Alliance recommends the use of only G-90 for roofing applications.

Galvalume steel combines the metallic coatings of both aluminum and zinc. This combination joins the healing properties of zinc with the superior barrier protection of aluminum. Galvalume steel offers superior weathering properties and is used in various application weights, the most common being AZ-55.

Aluminum
Aluminum is an affordable and extremely lightweight roofing material. It can be used either painted or unpainted; regardless, it will need a finish. Aluminum has a high coefficient of expansion, causing some thermal movement. Like steel, aluminum has a high strength-to-weight ratio. In addition, this material has excellent corrosion resistance and is ideal for coastal environments.


 Copper
Copper has a life expectancy measured in centuries; however, the material is very costly. Many will recognize copper roofs for the characteristic patina-green color that occurs when the copper oxidizes. Copper retains its original color when an acrylic layer is applied. Strong and very resistant to corrosion, copper is also easy to roll into sheets, but installation may be intricate.

Zinc
Zinc offers exceptional corrosion resistance. Like copper, this material also changes color as it oxidizes, turning a bluish-white. Zinc is malleable, enabling the creation of many attractive individual shingles and tiles.

 
Berridge Spanish tile is composed of interlocking steel barrel tiles attached in a structural panel system.
 Other Types of Metal
Terne and terne-coated stainless have all been used as roofing materials; however, they are rarely used today in residential metal-roofing applications. Terne requires repeated maintenance and painting, but offers excellent corrosion resistance. Terne-coated stainless requires no maintenance, will not rust or corrode, and weathers to a natural, matte-gray finish but it carries a hefty price tag.

TYPES OF PAINT PROCESSES

Field vs. Factory Painting
Most metal roofs are painted, and there are different processes for painting the metal roofing material. Field painting is one option, yet it is inefficient and lacks the quality found in factory-painted metals. Furthermore, field painting is an extremely expensive process and has a life expectancy of only five to seven years. Therefore, it is only used in exceptional circumstances or where damage has occurred.

On the other hand, factory painting produces a much higher quality finish that is typically warranted against chipping, peeling, fading, and chalking for various periods of time.

Giant rolls of flat metal in the factory receive a number of different layers of treatment. The initial coating is metallic -- either zinc, aluminum, or zinc-aluminum. This covering is applied to both the top side and the underside of the metal. The second layer, also applied on both sides of the metal, is the primer. The final layer is a base coat, applied to the underside of the sheet, and a premium paint or a granular coating for the top side. Through technology, the painting process can provide an even thickness, as well as a superior paint finish for a much more economical price.

Paint Resins
The production of metal roofs uses one of the three most common resins for panel paints: polyester and silicone resins (silicone-modified polymers - SMP), or fluoropolymers.

Polyester resins are widely used because of their relatively low cost. They have high gloss when applied, but will lose their glossiness over time. It is important to note that their color vibrance will diminish within five years.

SMP resins are different blends of polyester and silicone additives. These resins improve the performance properties of resins, are available in a variety of gloss levels, and will last longer than polyesters.

Fluoropolymers are technologically advanced and consist of a fluorinated polymer that contains unbeatable thermal-, chemical-, and UV-resistant properties. These resins have a high resistance to dirt retention and environmental aging, and are virtually maintenance free.

Kynar 500 and Hylar 5000 are trade names for a specific resin that uses a fluorocarbon compound. These resins have a medium-to-low gloss that resembles a teflon-like coating. They maintain color retention, repel dirt, and provide superior UV-light protection. The best protection level of Kynar and Hylar is a 70-percent formulation to ensure a longer life span. (One must specify them by name.)

ADVANTAGES OF METAL ROOFING

Standing-seam steel roofing holds the largest percentage of residential metal roofing in the industry. This type of roof is economical, attractive, and used in heavy snow areas. With a historical look that is gaining new popularity, standing seam is the oldest style of metal roofing that can be seen on traditional and restored buildings and homes.

In addition, the latest styles of metal roofs are catching the eye of many homeowners. The new metal-roofing products address all preferences by providing a variety of designs, styles, and colors to complement any type of architecture. As there are many advantages to standing-seam steel roofing, many of these attributes can be found with other recent styles of metal roofing.

Metal roofs are durable, offering a high-strength-to-low-weight ratio. These roofing systems are almost maintenance-free, no cleaning or pressure washing is needed, and will not lose impact resistance with age. Furthermore, metal roofs are low weight and can be installed over many existing roofs.

The advantages of a metal roof in severe weather are numerous. Metal roofs are fire retardant, providing a unfriendly home to fire-blown embers. In heavy snowstorms, metal roofs reflect radiant heat to melt ice and snow. In high winds, standing seam's fully interlocking panels can pass the Dade County, Fla., test -- withstanding winds over 110 miles per hour.

There are numerous environmental benefits of standing-seam metal roofs. Metal roofs are energy efficient; the metal reflects the heat and blocks heat transfer. Homeowners have reported a savings of up to 20% in their energy bills. Furthermore, steel roofs are made from 60-65% recyclable material and can be installed over existing roofs, eliminating excessive landfill disposal.

Standing-seam steel roofing is a complete system that includes factory- formed sheets and accessories, consistent protective finish, and overall protection. A metal roof is actually quiet, despite the misconception that they are noisy. Folds in the metal, solid decking, and insulation in the attic or ceiling muffle the sound of rain.

Cost Issues
While the initial cost for a premium metal roof is higher than most other roofing materials, the investment homeowners make for installing a metal roof will be returned over many years.

Installation Considerations
Many metal-roofing manufacturers have been reviewing the installation process and looking for ways to make it simpler and less labor intensive. Some metal manufacturers have been able to design a roofing system that needs only six common tools.

Furthermore, metal-roofing manufacturers have been designing products that do not require specialized training. Contractors can learn how to install a metal-roofing product through a brief presentation by the manufacturer or through a step-by-step video.

Future of Metal Roofing
Metal roofing will always be a roofing option, for both old and new homes and buildings. In the past few decades, metal roofing has evolved into a variety of styles and designs while maintaining its traditional standing-seam style. Even though standing seam still dominates the metal-roofing industry, other varieties and styles have also emerged, attracting many different audiences.



 The Metal Roofing Alliance (MRA) is a coalition of metal-roofing manufacturers, paint suppliers and coaters, dealers, metal producers, and related companies and associations. MRA's primary focus is to promote residential metal roofing and accelerate its growth. For more information, call 1-888 METAL ROOF, or consult the SourceList below.

Click Here for a list of METAL ROOFING SUPPLIERS from the Traditional Building Database

Articles Index

RETURN TO HOMEPAGE